Are you looking for a silky, creamy holiday pudding pie this season? Look no further! This one is amazing and easy to make. It is also 20% protein which is pretty unheard of for any pie!
6tbspPBFit Peanut Butter (you can use a different brand of peanut butter, but this one has more protein)
1/2cupPowdered Sugar
Get Recipe Ingredients
Prevent your screen from going dark
Instructions
Making the Vanilla Pudding
In a blender, add all the ingredients listed under the Vanilla Pudding heading and blend together until smooth and creamy.
Making the Chocolate Pudding
In a blender, add all the ingredients listed under the Chocolate Pudding heading and blend together until smooth and creamy.
Making the Topping
In a bowl, mix together the peanut butter and powdered sugar with a fork. You should end up with a bunch of tiny little balls/crumble of a powdered sugar peanut butter mixture.
Assembling the Pie
On your chocolate pie crust (you can make your own homemade one here; I just used store-bought for convenience) - pour you chocolate pudding. Smooth it out so you have a nice, even layer.
On top of the chocolate pudding, layer your vanilla pudding. Spread it out nicely so it's smooth and even.
Sprinkle your peanut butter powdered sugar crumble on top of the vanilla pudding. You should have enough to pretty much cover the entire pie.
Put this in the fridge to set for 1 - 2 hours minimum. It is never going to fully set firm like a baked pie but should end up easily scoop-able and serve-able after the fridge time.